The Smoking Gun - San Diego, CA

The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

The Smoking Gun is one of the newest bars in downtown San Diego, complete with a retro vibe and comfort food headed by powerhouse chef Kevin Templeton. We were invited to check out the new southern menu and dropped by to see what new direction this would take the location. I still remembered items like alcoholic slushies from Wet Willie's and asian fusion from Blush East+West Kitchen, the predecessors.

beef brisket at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Brandt Farms Beef Brisket ($12) - bbq au jus

Brisket is a meat that Dennis is experimenting with at home so we were curious how the chef prepared theirs. This tender meat had a very thin smoke ring but surprisingly the juices imbued that sought out smokiness. Dennis remarked that in this wet form, you can't get that brisket crust that he desires. Even though we were warned of this, the ratio of fat to meat was a little too high for our liking, at least 15-20% fat. Still, the meaty parts we did have were succulent and flavorful.

baked mac n cheese at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Baked Mac N Cheese ($6)

When done right, mac and cheese can make your heart flutter. Underneath this dish was a rich distribution of cheeses though the top cheddar layer was not Dennis's ideal topping. This thicker consistancy and ooey gooey cheese strands around al dente pasta were right up my alley though. My next brilliant idea was to pair this with the meaty parts of the brisket! I heard they recently won awards for their mac and cheese. Good job chef! 

cornmeal fried heirloom tomatoes at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Cornmeal Fried Heirloom Tomatoes ($7) - garlic aioli, housemade ranch

These fried tomatoes were so beautiful with their crisp cornmeal crust! Beneath that layer, the thick sliced tomatoes inside tasted just like pickles so Dennis was a huge fan. Pickle-haters like me might want to pass though! A tiny bit more sea salt would have accented this dish well. On the side were a ranchy dressing with dill and a creamier mayo-ish aioli dip.

sliders at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Pulled Lemon Chicken ($10 for 2) - green chili mustard, cheddar; BBQ Pulled Pork Sliders ($10 for 2) - bbq-mustard, red chili slaw

The sliders typically come in pairs of the same flavor but we requested singles for taste testing. Our absolute favorite item of the visit was this chicken slider. It gave a rotissarie chicken juiciness that dripped from the sandwich! The sauce had a hint of mustard without too much bite and paired perfectly. The buns were hardy but still soft enough to allow your teeth to sink in wonderfully. The meaty pork in the other slider looked like brisket to be honest. Topped with a BBQ inspired sauce, it held its own but was knocked out by the chicken.

chicken drummettes at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Lemon Peppered Chicken Drummettes ($12) - house made ranch, cali wing sauce

This oven finished chicken came out surrounded by juices within an aluminum foil wrap. This slow cooked texture reminded me of the chicken in my mom's homemade curry. The meaty little drumsticks had a simple salt and pepper seasoning but paled a bit compared to the flavorful slider. One sauce was the same as the fried green tomatoes but other one had a spicy kick like salsa verde. 

retro view finder for drinks at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Relive your childhood (or at least for us) with this viewer master! Several of the cocktails were pictured in the slide show. 

cocktails at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

I'm Turning Japanese ($13) - Toki japanese whisky, blood orange amaro, toasted pecan bitters

Goodbye Island ($13) - cruzan rum, passionfruit, lime, pineapple, serrano chile

Dennis ordered a whiskey drink that was too "whiskey" strong for this girl. The second was more to my style with a delicious sweetness especially because I requested it without the chile. No spicy for me!

The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Inside the restaurant was a center bar with multiple television screens for watching sports. It was busy but not rowdy on that Football Sunday. I noticed they had some great football specials too.

ping pong at The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

For additional entertainment, you could challenge someone to ping pong or shuffleboards. The background pic is motivating us to pull out our own ping pong table for some fast paced action!

The Smoking Gun in downtown San Diego

Our check came out in a Madonna cd which fit with the throwback theme of the restaurant. Our waitress Katie took good care of us though service was a little spotty once in a while sitting on the patio. They have daily promotions worth checking out if you are in the area. I think this place has lots of promise, especially with Chef Kevin Templeton on board the team. We'll drop by again when the restaurant is more established in a few months.

Disclaimer: We were invited to dine here and our food and drink were complimentary. We were not otherwise compensated and all opinions stated are our own

The Smoking Gun
555 Market St
San Diego CA 92101
(619) 233-3836

Share this post on...


Laura @ Sprint 2 the Table's picture
Submitted by Laura @ Sprint ... (not verified) on Thu, 11/09/2017 - 6:45pm

I didn't know this had opened! That chicken slider had be salivating just reading about it. And the whiskey. ;)

lynn's picture
Submitted by lynn on Mon, 11/13/2017 - 10:01am

i didn't want to share the slider but i gotta be nice to hubby... =P

soo's picture
Submitted by soo (not verified) on Mon, 11/13/2017 - 2:14pm

Great looking brisket! I usually go to Grand Ole BBQ when I want some.

lynn's picture
Submitted by lynn on Fri, 11/17/2017 - 6:35pm

Grand Ole has some great brisket! I'm always afraid of the long lines so haven't been in a while...

Add new comment